Great to hear the
Pure Reason Revolution interview.
------------------------------------------------------------------
Interesting discussion on the prog debate and so refreshing to hear a band postive about prog as a musical genre whilst acknowledging the image issues.
Chloe certainly has a point about the accessibility, particularly some of the stage antics in the 70s that attracted media critcism and would put some people off today.
My own experience was that I loved ELP music, never saw them live, but did see a DVD with Keith Emerson on a revolving piano and had to agree that was perhaps a stunt too far!
As to how to define prog:
1) Is it a particular brand of music in the cretaive 70s so therefore prog today infers it is recreating that music in a nostalgic way?
2) is it an ever evolving imaginative genre that fits no other category than prog, in terms of still pushing the boundaries?
People will argue this for as long as Dark Side of The Moon remains in the album charts.
I think that prog, even much of that produced in the 70s, often still sounds timeless today. And long ago I decided to term this style, be it modern, or 70s, as quality rock, in that it has musicianship and imagination.
Nothing wrong with compact tracks, i.e no padding! Indeed it makes airplay a lot easier and to be fair people just haven't the time they used to have. This is the age of instant communications and "I want it all I want it now culture". There is greater competition on everyone's leisure time , older and younger!
That said, many of the long tracks in 70s prog were a patch-work quilt of many tracks sewn together take Supper's Ready for example - full of variety. Others though were clearly padded out and many people today would switch off if the variety wasn't strong enough to carry their attention.
Probably no harm in being compared to early Pink Floyd as a musical reference.
Odd we don't get the mainstream-media moaning as much about reproducing the poppy 60s and pop side of The Beatles sound in particular. Take Brit-pop etc and many of the "new" bands of today and you might as well be back in the 60s. Yet when it comes to prog, the rules suddenly change! Also classical music can have concept albums and have long pieces - yet we don't hear the same hatred in the media.
I hope bands like Pure Reason Revolution put this style of music back on the musical map in a positive way, and attract new blood and new ideas into this underrated area of music - whatever the media label it!
Great to hear the band and I can't wait to buy the album!
By the way thanks to Ralph for airing and sharing the Gary Numan track, I bought his earlier albums, along with those by a band called Magazine. The synths were fantastic and Are Freinds Electric still has that edge!